Anti-Discrimination Law

Print
Comment
Volume 91.8
Weighing In: Why Obesity Should Be Considered a Qualifying Disability Under the Americans with Disabilities Act
Anne Marie Hawley
B.A. 2019, Georgetown University; J.D. Candidate 2025, The University of Chicago Law School.

I would like to thank Professor Sarah Konsky, Professor Katie Eyer, and the editors of the University of Chicago Law Review for their guidance and helpful feedback. Special thanks are also due to activist Aubrey Gordon and journalist Michael Hobbes, whose tireless advocacy inspired my research topic.

Anti-fat bias has been described as the last socially acceptable form of prejudice. Despite the discrimination that fat people face, there is no federal protection against weight discrimination. One potential solution to the lack of existing legal protections is the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Claims challenging weight discrimination under the ADA argue that weight discrimination is a form of disability discrimination that is based on the medical condition of obesity. Yet, courts have resisted granting the ADA’s protections to obese plaintiffs.

This Comment argues that courts should recognize obesity as an ADA-protected disability, even in circuits that have restricted obesity-as-a-disability ADA claims to cases where a plaintiff can show that their obesity is related to a physiological disorder. The author draws parallels between obesity and gender dysphoria to highlight courts’ recent willingness to extend the ADA’s protection to highly stigmatized clinical conditions when a diagnosis has gained credibility in the medical community and evidence suggests that the condition has a physiological cause.